Nana: Visual Tragedy (Spoilers!)

Nana: Visual Tragedy (Spoilers!)

There are many, many spoilers here, so if you have not  read volume 21 of Nana, you may want to avoid reading this.

In Volume 21 of Nana, Ren gets into a car crash and passes away. Ren’s death is so tragic that it’s impossible for me to read or think about it without tearing up. Yet my reaction to Ren’s death would not have been as painful without Ai Yazawa’s wonderfully expressive artwork. Instead of relying on dialogue, Yazawa’s art helps convey sorrow in a dramatic yet completely realistic way, so that we not only empathize with the characters but are absorbed into their world.

page 60:

Nobu and Takumi identify Ren's body

page 61:

Ai Yazawa’s artistic craft is used to give each character a distinguished reaction to the tragedy that suits their established personalities. Nobu’s body is drawn in a way that it appears to be hurling itself away from the sight of Ren, expressing Nobu’s shock and horror. His tears and anguished facial expressions capture his pain in ways words could not possibly. Takumi’s expressions capture the stages of his disbelief, until he closes his eyes in painful reconciliation.

page 76:

The scene is messy and drawn dramatically, perfectly capturing the passionate energy of Reira’s character. Her body is hurling towards Ren, serving as a contrast to the earlier image of Nobu. These memorable images also serve as dramatic irony, since later on Reira’s denial about Ren’s death becomes so strong that she represses her memories of the tragedy.

page 100:

This was perhaps the most striking panel for me when I read volume 21 of Nana. It’s so simple but extremely effective; because even though we are looking into a room filled with major characters, the room feels completely cold and empty. While earlier panels are frenetic, full of movement and flooding tears, this scene allows both the characters and the audience a moment of silence. The panel captures the inner turmoil of these characters, framing their emotions after the fact that their friend has died has sunk in. Even though we can’t see any of the character’s faces, their limp bodies tell us that they are worn out from crying. After seeing this image, all of my feelings became overwhelming and my tears turned into cold sobs.

page 102:

page 108:

As seen in the first panel, Nana is initially numb to the news of Ren’s death, and says that she wants to continue her music tour as if nothing has happened.  It’s only when Yasu tells Nana to say goodbye to Ren because it will be her last chance to that scenes of her and Ren flash before her eyes. Her pain finally begins to register with her, and tears well up in her eyes. However, it’s too much for her to process, and she avoids thinking about Ren to the point of lashing out at those around her. As the pieces are falling together to connect the present to the future, it is likely Nana’s unwillingness to accept Ren’s death that has caused her to run away from everything – from opening his birthday present to her, to eventually leaving behind all of her friends. From Ren’s demise, many other tragedies silently bloomed.

Tragedy is hard to convey because it can feel manipulative, as if it’s forcing the reader to cry.  Death is not as effective when it is over the top, such as if all the characters were screaming ‘He’s dead! I can’t believe he’s dead!!’ Instead, Nana uses subtlety, making Ren’s death one of the most beautifully poignant and memorable moments I’ve ever read.


7 thoughts on “Nana: Visual Tragedy (Spoilers!)

  1. When i started to read volume 21 0f Nana i simply weeped non stop, the images and the caracters suffering was so strong that i cried, i cry even remenbering such sad moment. I fell like Nana lost her only family, her soulmate, and that is really heartbreaking. Can´t wait for Ai Yazawa to continue the manga, but the worst is that we might never get an end to this amazing story.

    1. I think it’s really hard to read this volume and not cry; that’s how well written it is. I’m afraid of the series not ever being finished, and there are so many questions that are up in the air that I would love to be answered, but I appreciate what has been created so far. Even though volume 21 is not where I would want Nana to end, if it does, I think it’ll still be a wonderful series regardless.

  2. I was a little slow with catching up on Nana, but reading that series.. I can’t help but feel awful. It has really depressed me, even though I know Ren is fictional. He was a great character despite his faults. He also chose a beautiful name for Hachi’s child. I hope Ai will someday release more of Nana.

    1. Thanks for commenting! I know exactly how you feel – although I know the characters in Nana are fictional, their stories feel like they could have happened, and you get so attached to them, which is why I want to find out what will happen next. And I agree that Satsuki’s a pretty name.

  3. I had already spoiled Ren’s death for myself through Wikipedia and through this post (bad habit!), but despite that, your analysis of these scenes actually increased their impact on me when I finally got to them. Even before I read vol. 21, just visualizing these scenes on their own made me want to tear up. Nana is the first manga that’s made me cry, and I think that’s partly due to how much more mindful I was of the art (I tend to speed-read through manga) because of your post, so thanks!

    1. Aww, thank you! But don’t give me too much credit – Yazawa does such an amazing job with these scenes that I’m sure they would have impacted you no matter what. And many times just remembering this part of the series is enough to make me cry. I’m sorry this post spoiled you – I don’t like spoilers myself but sometimes I can’t help but want to read on and find out what happens when I’m reading posts from other bloggers on series I’m in the middle of reading or watching.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s